Lizzie Borden took an axe
And gave her mother forty whacks.
When she saw what she had done,
She gave her father forty-one.
Way back in the day, August 4, 1892 to be exact, two horrendous murders took place in Fall River Massachusetts. Andrew and Abbey Borden were brutally murdered in their home by someone wielding a hatchet that chopped their heads into tiny messy bits. All signs pointed to one of their daughters, the infamous Lizzie Borden. She had the means, the motive, and her alibis were as solid as jello.
|The Borden Homestead|
Leading up to the murders there had been a fair amount of turmoil with the wealthy family. Andrew Borden was handing out parcels of land to extended family members and the two daughters, Lizzie and Emma Borden where non-too-thrilled with their father’s decisions. On the day the murders occurred the uncle, John, had just left for town after spending the night in the Borden home guest room. Emma was out of town, and Bridget, the maid, had just laid down to rest after washing windows on the sweltering August day.
Abby Borden, Lizzie’s step mother, was the first to die. She was hit in the back of the head with a hatchet while cleaning the guest room. The first strike managed to kill her, but her assailant continued his/her attack totaling 18 strikes to the back of the head. Her death was placed around 9:30 am.
Around 10:30 am Andrew Borden returned home from the bank, and Lizzie reportedly helped him get comfortable in the living room before wandering off to somewhere else for 20 minutes. At 11:10am Lizzie called out for the maid, and it was discovered that her father’s face had been hacked into 11 times. The blood was still flowing when the maid arrived on the scene.
When Lizzie was questioned as to where she was during the time of the murders her story went from spending 20 or so minutes in the barn looking for iron to fix a door and then eating pears in the loft to wandering the barn for 10 minutes looking for sinkers for a fishing trip her father was planning. Lizzie was eventually arrested after an ash smeared hatchet was found in the basement with the handle broken off. She was even brought to trial for both murders. However, no hard evidence was ever found linking her to the murders so she was found innocent on all charges. The main reason she was acquitted was because no blood was ever found on Lizzie. No clothing or shoes with bloodstains, and no spatter on her person when the event transpired.
Today her home is a quaint little bed and breakfast where you can stay in the reportedly haunted rooms. The room where Abbey Borden was murdered is now a very sought after room called the ‘John Morse Guestroom’. It has a quaint framed copy of Mrs. Borden’s crime-scene photo hung on the wall next to the bed. And, fun fact, they have a virtual tour of the room, but you have to subscribe to see it 😦
|The John Morse Guestroom|
The staff believe beyond a doubt that the Inn is haunted. Here’s an excerpt of one of their stories from Haunted Inns of New England by Mark Jasper:
” The […] incident took place a month and a half after the Bed and Breakfast had opened for business. Housekeeping had just finished cleaning the rooms and making the beds. One of the housekeepers walked back into the John Morse Guest room and suddenly fled down the stairs, ran through the gift shop, and out of the Inn, never to return. The housekeeper said when she entered the room, she walked over to the commode stand to put the sheets away. When she turned around she saw the imprint of a body on the bed.”
The guests apparently have had some strange experiences as well, “Some have reported hearing a woman sobbing on the third floor, while others have seen an apparition of an older woman with gray hair wearing dark Victorian clothing. She is usually seen doing various chores, such as dusting or pulling up the blankets on the bed.”
Hungry for more?
If you’re interested in booking a stay you should check out the Lizzie Borden Bed and Breakfast
If you’d like to read more tales of haunted inns check out Haunted Inns of New England
For more about Lizzie Borden and her trial check out some of these links: